Frequently asked questions about MPAs
What are MPAs?Good question. The acronym stands for Marine Protected Areas. This is a generic term used worldwide to refer to an area of sea which benefits from a range of levels of protection. However just to confuse you, here in Scotland we also use it to refer to the sites that will be designated in Scottish waters (out to the limit of the UK continental shelf, beyond 200nm in some places) under the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010 and the Marine and Coastal Access Act 2009. There can be three types of MPA in Scotland arising from these laws – nature conservation MPAs, demonstration and research MPAs and historic MPAs. To complicate things further, Scotland’s emerging “MPA network” will also include marine-based Special Areas of Conservation (SACs), Special Protection Areas (SPAs), intertidal Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSIs) and Ramsar sites. To simplify this acronym overload, on this website MPAs refer to the ‘nature conservation MPAs’ in Scotland unless we specify otherwise.
What are MPAs for?Scotland’s shores make up 10% of the European coastline (Argyll alone has a coastline longer than that of France). Our seas are rich in marine life: home to 23 species of whales and dolphins and an estimated 40,000+ species in total. But only 4% of our territorial waters are currently protected by Special Areas of Conservation (SAC) designations – and those protect just four species and eight habitat types. Unfortunately, the marine environment is not as healthy as it used to be. Many of Scotland’s marine species have declined and seabed habitats have been damaged due to a range of pressures, from climate change to human exploitation. We are very much part of this damaged ecosystem too. The marine ‘sectors’ (everything from marine tourism to fishing to the oil and gas industry) employ around 40,000 people and they depend on a well-managed marine environment. We have taken advantage of this diverse environment’s ability to provide us with a vast range of goods and services, and it still remains at the forefront of our food and energy needs. If the health of our seas is not looked after, the wider health of Scotland is put at risk. A well-managed network of MPAs would not only help protect the wildlife and habitats that currently exist, but also help Scotland’s seas to recover. Individual sites chosen to protect particular habitats or species (MPA protected features) will form part of a more comprehensive and ‘ecologically coherent’ network around Scotland’s shores. For this network to be most effective in improving the health of our seas it needs to be ‘ecologically coherent’ (see ‘What is an ecologically coherent network?’ below for more information). This is a long way of saying something simple: a network of MPAs will help Scotland’s seas recover.
How many are needed for Scotland?The Scottish Government has not set a precise target for the number of MPAs it wants to identify, or a total surface area it wants the sites to cover. Sites simply need to be in the right places, in sufficient number, adequately replicated and of individual sufficient size to represent the range of features to be protected and recovered. 30 new nature conservation MPAs were recently designated (July 2014), but more protection is needed, particularly for mobile species.
Where are the MPAs?The MPAs identified and designated so far have included inshore sites such as Loch Sween, as well as sites much further out to sea such as Hatton Bank. Have a look at our webmap to find out more.
Are MPAs the same as No Take Zones?No. MPAs are not the same as No Take Zones (which prohibit any form of extraction from the marine area, except for strictly-licensed research purposes). A wide range of activities will be permitted within Marine Protected Areas, for which the Scottish Government have indicated there will be a presumption of sustainable use – the crucial point is that these activities must be managed and coordinated so that they do not adversely impact the marine environment and allow it to recover where necessary. For example, sensitive fishing practices that are compatible with the protection and recovery of an MPA’s protected features will be able to continue. Practices that cause damage must be diverted away from sensitive features. The exact management measures will depend on what features the MPA is set up to protect and recover.
Could I still go rockpooling on a beach that is inside an MPA?Of course! Marine Protected Areas will not prevent anyone from continuing to use and enjoy their beaches and shores for rockpooling, snorkelling and other such fine pursuits. All we would advise is that everybody abide by the MCS seashore code, which they should do wherever they go, whether inside or outside MPAs. Commercial fishing may also be permitted within an MPA.
How do we know what is worthwhile protecting?Compared to 100 years ago, we now know a fair amount more about the ecology, geology and oceanography of Scotland’s coastal and offshore waters. Decades of research and scientific fieldwork on a host of marine species and habitats has produced an emerging map of Scotland’s seas (see Scotland’s Marine Atlas). Increasingly sophisticated geomorphological and bathymetric modelling also means that seabed habitat mapping is becoming more accurate. However, there is still a lot that we don’t know. That is why identifying the marine protected area network must be based on the best available science. Data gaps or uncertainties can mean it’s hard to entirely conclusive answer; we must therefore take a ‘precautionary approach.’ Where information is limited we should not use this as a reason to postpone or fail to take measures to protect the environment. If the evidence points one way, it is incumbent on the Scottish Parliament to take action.
Will MPAs help fish stocks recover?These new MPAs are not designed specifically to help fish stocks recover – the continued overhaul of the EU’s Common Fisheries Policy and more effective inshore fisheries management is needed for that. But they could provide secondary benefits for local fisheries. If well-managed and well-enforced, MPAs can play an important role in helping fish and shellfish stocks recover as a result of protecting important habitats. To allow fish stocks to fully recover, MPAs must be used in tandem with other measures such as marine planning and sustainable fisheries management. Many of the MPA protected features will provide vital habitats and food for other species and so protecting important areas for feeding and breeding and other key life stages will help protect a whole range of species in the food web. The potential for this effect makes MPAs part of an exciting project to restore Scotland’s seas.
Will MPAs be permanent?The Scottish Government will carry out a six-yearly review of MPAs to ensure they are meeting, or are making progress towards meeting, their conservation objectives. Progress on the designation, status and journey towards achieving conservation objectives will be reported to the Scottish Parliament. Following such a review, it would be possible to de-select a specific MPA if it cannot meet its objectives or if new information becomes available that indicates another area would contribute more to protecting a particular feature. In this case one or more new MPAs would need to be selected to replace it.
How will MPAs interact with industry?Scotland’s seas are getting increasingly busy. Plans for renewable energy (wind, wave and tidal) and expanding aquaculture now sit alongside continued oil and gas exploration, shipping and both inshore and offshore fishing. Some forms of all these activities, depending on their scale and nature, may be compatible with the conservation objectives and the management measures set up for individual MPAs, with developments able to progress in harmony with the Scottish Government’s duty to protect and enhance Scotland’s seas. Alongside the National Marine Plan, MPAs will help developers navigate what is a complex planning environment.
Who is proposing MPAs?In one sense, we all are. In the years leading up to 2010, Scottish voters showed their support for ambitious marine legislation which would protect and restore our seas, for so long overlooked and often over-exploited. The Marine (Scotland) Act was given Royal Assent in March 2010 which gave Scottish Ministers powers to create MPAs. Since then Scottish Natural Heritage, the Joint Nature Conservation Committee and Marine Scotland have been working together to identify sites for MPAs. Third parties, such as community groups and environmental NGOs like ourselves, also had the opportunity to make a scientific case for new MPAs, in some cases successfully. In other words, the Scottish Government is carrying out the detailed work to identify possible options and will then consult us, the Scottish people, on their recommendations. Ultimately, it will be Ministers who decide which sites will be designated, but during the consultation phase we all have the opportunity to put our views forward. It will be vital that the Scottish Government and Ministers hear strong public support for MPAs at this stage.
Who supports MPAs?Everyone who is part of Save Scottish Seas supports MPAs as well as many others. A number of marine protected areas have been proposed by community organisations in Scotland, such as the South Arran MPA and Fair Isle demonstration and research MPA – so there is evident and growing support for them around our coastal towns and villages. Hopefully as we learn more about what each site will mean for local communities and industry, the benefits and possible socio-economic opportunities will become more apparent and better understood.
What is an ‘ecologically coherent network’ of MPAs?In the past, protected areas have been created largely on the merits of individual locations with little or no consideration given to how these sites could work together – as part of a network. The Scottish Government has committed to creating an ‘ecologically coherent’ network of marine protected areas. As described above this network will be composed of existing protected areas, such as Special Areas of Conservation, as well as the new MPAs to be designation under the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010 and the Marine and Coastal Access Act 2009. It is important these sites work together to maximise the benefits to our seas, so the design of the network needs to:• replicate features in separate protected areas within the network to safeguard against unexpected failures or collapse of populations,• represent the full range of marine habitats and wildlife found in Scotland’s seas, • allow connections between sites so they can link and support each other by taking advantage of ocean currents, migration routes and other natural ecological connections • create sites which are a suitable size and shape to encompass ecological processes and the home ranges of protected features.
Is the MPA network in sight? What stage of the process are we at?We are now at a critical stage of the process. The Scottish Government is currently consulting on proposed management for inshore ncMPAs and SACs. To find out how we got to this point, read this short history of MPAs in Scotland.
What concerns does Save Scottish Seas have about the proposed network?In short, we are concerned that Scottish MPAs could become paper parks. Without effective management and strong objectives to recover our struggling sealife, the MPAs will simply not improve the damaged health of our wider seas. You can read our detailed consultation responses here and support our DontTakeTheP out of MPAs campaign.
How long will it take before the proposals are implemented?Unfortunately it’s difficult to say. The UK and Scottish Governments made a commitment under the international OSPAR Convention to establish a network of ecologically coherent MPAs by 2012. We are already falling behind that schedule, but the Scottish Government is committed to putting in place a well-managed network by 2016. 2016 may sound like a long time away, but the processes to identify, designate and agree management measures can be slow, so rapid progress is urgently needed. While decisions on the location of sites needs to be based on science, it is important that communities across Scotland engage in the process so there is a common understanding of the vital role MPAs will play in helping to safeguard all that we enjoy from sea, such as food, energy, recreation and climate regulation. It is hoped that the proposals will be designated by the end of 2013 with on-going discussions about specific management measures running possibly beyond this. So the simple answer is: nobody knows yet. The Save Scottish Seas campaign will push for the network to be put in place as soon as is practically possible.
How do I make my own views known?The Scottish Government is in a complex process of consultation with many different stages. To keep up-to-date with the next steps in the development of MPAs, you can get in touch with members of Scottish Environment LINK’s Marine Taskforce through the Save Scottish Seas website to share your views and ideas or to ask any other questions about the MPA process. Check our #SupportMPAs – campaign update page too.
Scottish Environment LINK consultation responses (on MPAs)
Scottish Environment LINK briefings
Marine Protected Areas – The Economic Benefits (Briefing 4)If correctly implemented, MPAs can have major economic benefits. This briefing provides an overview of those benefits. Download here
Marine Protected Areas – Ecologically Coherent Networks (Briefing 3)Here we explore the key elements of creating an ecologically coherent network of marine protected areas. This is a particularly important issue as the overall design of the network and its implementation must be ‘ecologically coherent’ to meet OSPAR obligations. Download here
Marine Protected Areas – The Selection Process (Briefing 2)Read for a quick overview about the Scottish Government’s designation process for new nature conservation Marine Protected Areas under the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010. Download here
Marine Protected Areas – An Introduction (Briefing 1)The first in a series of briefings from Scottish Environment LINK’s Marine Taskforce, exploring Scotland’s new Marine Protected Area network. Download here
Scientific papers & research
Ecological CoherenceEcological Coherence Definitions in Policy and Practice Aspen International for Scottish Natural Heritage Rondinini, C. (2011)A review of methodologies that could be used to formulate ecologically meaningful targets for marine habitat coverage within the UK MPA network Joint Nature Conservation Council Natural England and JNCC (2010)Marine Conservation Zone Project: Ecological network guidance Boedeker, D. Paulomäki, H. Ranft, S. (2010)Towards an ecologically coherent network of well-managed Marine Protected AreasBaltic Marine Environment Protection Commission. Gubbay, S. (2009)Network of Marine Protected Areas in Northern Ireland: A briefing for the Northern Ireland Marine Task Force. NIMTF IUCN World Commission on Protected Areas (IUCN-WCPA) (2008).Establishing Resilient Marine Protected Area Networks—Making It Happen. Washington, D.C.: IUCN-WCPA, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and The Nature Conservancy. p.118 Laffoley, D. d’A. (ed) (2008)
Towards Networks of Marine Protected Areas. The MPA Plan of Action for IUCN’s World Commission on Protected Areas. IUCN WCPA, Gland, Switzerland. Piekäinen, H. & Korpinen, S. (eds) (2008)
Towards an Assessment on Ecological Coherence of the Marine Protected Areas Network in the Baltic Sea Region. BALANCE Interim Report No. 25, pp. 1–140. Balance, Copenhagen, Denmark. Ballantine, W.J. & Langlois, T.J. (2007)
Marine Reserves: The Need for Systems. Leigh Marine Laboratory, University of Auckland Helsinki Commission (2007)
Assessment of Ecological Coherence of the OSPAR MPA Network. Nature Protection and Biodiversity Group. Doc: 5.2/4/INF OSPAR (2006)
Guidance on developing an ecologically coherent network of OSPAR Marine Protected Areas. London: OSPAR Commission, 2006. Staub, F & Hatziolos, M.E. (2004)
Score Card to Assess Progress in Achieving Management Effectiveness Goals for Marine Protected Areas. The World Bank, Washington DC, USA. Bennett, G. & Wit, P (2001)
The Development and Application of Ecological Networks: A Review of Proposals, Plans and Programmes. IUCN and AID Environment, Amsterdam
Socio-economics of MPAsExcellent resources on the socio-ecomomic impacts of MPAs can be found via the resources pages of the Marine Socio Economics Project.